Jump to navigation


Farmers and fishermen free to sue Shell in landmark case

Legal battles proliferate over pollution and tax as government braces for oil decline

As the pandemic recession and the push for a green energy transition hasten the winding down of the hydrocarbon economy, big oil companies are contending with falling profits and a raft of lawsuits in western courts. Many of the cases are being fought around production in Africa and Asia where companies are accused of exploiting lax regulatory systems.

Most of them are about citizens hit by environmental despoliation or contractual disputes between resource companies and the state authorities. The continuing salvos between Nigeria and Shell cover all the bases.

Pressure over revenues is on both sides. A new report by the Natural Resource Governance Institute calculates that national oil companies in Algeria, Congo-Brazzaville, Mozambique and Nigeria are investing $400 billion in oil projects that will not break even by 2030 if industrial economies meet international obligations for cutting carbon emissions.

Oil-producing countries are reviewing contracts with the multinationals, aiming to pull in more investment over the next decade in what might be the industry's last gasp. 

Legal fights will hamper those efforts for the most part. Often, they are three-cornered: the citizens and complainants; the international oil company; and the national government which is a co-shareholder with the oil company in local production.

On 12 February, Britain's Supreme Court ruled that 42,500 fishermen and farmers from the Ogale and Billie communities could sue Royal Dutch Shell for the failure of its subsidiary SPDC to clean up multiple pipeline leaks in the Niger Delta. The case brought by London law firm Leigh Day sets a common law precedent that will also apply in Australia, Canada and New Zealand.

As the biggest foreign oil producer in Nigeria, Shell is a favoured target of campaigners but all of its operations partner either with the state-owned oil company or other multinationals or both.

SPDC operates pipelines across the Delta: it is owned by the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (55%); Shell (30%); France's Total (10%); and Italy's ENI (5%). Two weeks earlier Shell lost a case in Dutch appeal courts which again held it liable for leaking pipelines.

None of the litigants are putting a figure on the damages which could be decided in a trial. Shell and the other companies may prefer to settle out of court. Shell paid over $80 million in an out-of-court settlement in 2015 to the Bodo community for two oil spills. 

At the time, it was the biggest settlement ever agreed for oil spills in Nigeria but activists expect a better offer after the latest court ruling in London. After the 12 February ruling, Shell's chief executive Ben van Beurden said the company would take another hard look at its onshore production in Nigeria. That probably means selling more assets (AC Vol 61 No 25, Unbalancing the books & AC Vol 61 No 20, How to make oil pay).

Related Articles

Unbalancing the books

Promises of grand economic growth have been torpedoed by the Covid-19 pandemic and crashing oil prices

This time last year President Muhammadu Buhari and his numerous economic policymakers were optimistic that 2020 could see growth acceleration, job creation, significant infrastruct...

How to make oil pay

After 20 years of lobbying, a bill to reform the country’s energy industry is being pushed through the National Assembly – with a good chance of success

There has been consensus in the country on two things since the return to civil rule in 1999: the management of oil and gas, which dominates the export economy, is deeply flawed; a...

Homage to Catalonia

As their central governments fight secessionists this week, Nigeria and Spain discover they have a few things in common 

Proponents of Biafra as an independent state in south-east Nigeria have seized upon the Spanish government's mishandling of the Catalonian secessionists to score propaganda points ...


The governor's dues

Oil shut downs and political violence are escalating despite record budgets in the Delta

Despite a record budget of US$1.2 billion for 2006, Rivers State government isn't helping those worst hit by the violence and oil shut downs in the Niger Delta. And there is no vis...

A moment of truth for the General

Returning to power after 30 years, Muhammadu Buhari has been elected President heading a coalition bent on reform

One of the first acts of President-elect Muhammadu Buhari's new government will be to establish a clear regime of accountability and transparency in managing the country's oil and ...