Jump to navigation

Vol 62 No 3

Published 4th February 2021


Guinea

Steinmetz gets five years for bribery

Judge Alexandra Banna in Geneva says that 'Steinmetz was the main beneficiary' of a criminal operation to secure mining rights in Guinea. 'All important decisions were taken with his agreement'

A Geneva court sentenced mining magnate Beny Steinmetz to five years in prison on 22 January for bribery and money-laundering. The bribes were paid to obtain rights to mine the vast Simandou iron ore deposit in Guinea and the money-laundering charges concerned the fictitious transactions which concealed the source of the bribes (AC Vol 62 No 2, Inside the Swiss charges against Steinmetz and passim).

Steinmetz was found to have paid millions of dollars to Mamadie Touré, one of then-Guinean President Lansana Conté's four wives, for the mining licences between 2006 and 2012. Her influence ensured the blocks were stripped from mining giant Rio Tinto in December 2008 and handed to Beny Steinmetz Group Resources (BSGR).

BSGR paid nothing for the rights – although it claimed to have invested $160 million – and then sold 51% on to major Brazilian miner Vale for $2.5 billion. Vale won a $2bn award against BSGR in arbitration in London in April 2019, and it is suing Steinmetz and five of his associates for payment.

The President of Geneva's Tribunal Correctionnel, Alexandra Banna, said that BSGR's denials of the bribery were 'absurd' and 'mendacious', and that Steinmetz played a direct role, reports Switzerland's Tribune de Genève. The payments were the result of a 'one sole wish: to corrupt the Guinean president', she said. The case made Swiss history as its first ever international bribery trial.

Steinmetz's main middleman in obtaining the licences, Frédéric Cilins, got three-and-a-half years, and a 5 million Swiss franc fine. Cilins established and largely managed the relationship with Touré. He was sentenced to two years in prison in New York in 2014 for obstructing justice by trying to bribe Touré to destroy incriminating evidence of contracts with BSGR and its middlemen, while being secretly recorded by the FBI.

Steinmetz has said he will appeal, and he will remain at liberty during that process. He had argued he was no more than an adviser and roving ambassador for the company that bore his name. Cilins's defence was that the payments were not bribes but pre-financing for a joint business in food products. 

A third defendant, Sandra Merloni-Horemans, received a two-and-a-half year suspended sentence and SFr50,000 fine, for her role. Merloni-Horemans, who had worked as a company administrator for Steinmetz and his father for over 20 years, says she had no role beyond processing documentation on instructions from company executives. 

See Africa Confidential's exclusive account of the prosecution case and the evidence in the trial, Inside the Swiss charges against Steinmetz.



Related Articles

Pushing for probity

Pressure is growing for greater accountability and transparency in oil and mining operations, especially in Africa, due to the strengthening of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative and the imminent application of the United States’ Dodd-Frank Act. Yet major disagreements between companies, governments and anti-corruption activists emerged at the EITI’s biennial conference in Paris on 2-3 March, its biggest ever. Large oil companies, led by Royal Dutch Shell, argue that any extension of the compulsory accountability provisions of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act would undermine voluntary agreements such as EITI (AC Vol 51 No 19).

European and African officials backed moves at the Paris conference to toughen laws on company payment disclosures, despite strong opposition from oil and mining companies, including some who...


Dam payment

President Conté's ministers are the latest African team to negotiate a massive minerals-for-infrastructure countertrade deal

Officials from Guinea’s Ministry of Mines are due in Beijing to negotiate a US$21 billion countertrade deal to swap bauxite and iron ore concessions for investments in dams,...


How honesty can cost jobs

Local officials and Western companies argue about new regulations on conflict minerals which they say could worsen economic hardship

Unemployment among artisanal miners is rising as nervous electronics manufacturers, such as Apple and Intel, source fewer imports from them. Many companies are acting on a precautionary basis...


Starting guns

The new government has started by shooting school children. On 12 June, five died in Conakry, two in Nzérékoré, some 970 kilometres south-east of the capital, and four...