Jump to navigation

Nigeria

Abuja gets $11bn claim on gas deal overturned in London's High Court

President Tinubu says judgement was a blow against economic malpractice and the exploitation of Africa

The end of the $11 billion failed gas project case against the Nigerian government is in sight after London High Court Judge Robin Knowles ruled on 23 October that claimants, Process & Industrial Development, had acted fraudulently.

Judge Knowles found that P&ID had paid bribes to a Nigerian oil industry official linked to the project to build a gas processing plant in Cross River State first mooted in 2010 (AC Vol 61 No 11, The $10 billion gas plant that never was).

That unpicks P&ID's claim of over $11bn against Nigeria which was based on a decision by an arbitration panel in London which in 2017 had awarded the company $6.6bn for lost profits after it asserted that Nigeria had reneged on its obligations in the project (AC Vol 61 No 15, Fight in the last chance saloon).

The panel added that Nigeria would be liable for interest payments on the sum awarded, bringing the total claimed by P&ID to over $11bn this month.

The next stage in the case is for the Court to consider cancelling the award – completely or in part. Nigeria wants the whole award cancelled and may seek damages from P&ID for the financial costs resulting from the action – such as raising the cost of Nigeria's borrowing or undermining its investment prospects. And Nigeria will certainly seek the payment of its legal costs – amounting to tens of millions of dollars – from P&ID.

Judge Knowles concluded on 23 October that the gas deal between P&ID and the Nigerian petroleum ministry was 'obtained by fraud' and 'procured … contrary to public policy.'

'This case has also, sadly, brought together a combination of examples of what some individuals will do for money. Driven by greed and prepared to use corruption; giving no thought to what their enrichment would mean in terms of harm for others,' Knowles added.

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu and his predecessor Muhammadu Buhari had refused to settle the case out of court. Defeat would have put the government on the hook for a third of its current foreign exchange reserves (AC Vol 64 No 12, Tinubu tries shock therapy on sluggish economy & Vol 64 No 16, Amid protests over spiralling prices, Tinubu names new team).

The ruling that P&ID's claim was fraudulent will embarrass Britain's former Home Secretary Priti Patel who had argued in an opinion column that Nigeria has an obligation to pay P&ID's claim if it wanted to be seen a country embracing the rule of law and safe destination for international investors. To date Patel has declined to comment on her support for P&ID and her public endorsement of a company judged guilty of corruption in the London High Court.



Related Articles

The $10 billion gas plant that never was

Abuja challenges a gigantic court judgement against it by arguing that the claimants had planned it all as a scam from the start

Faced with the prospect of its oil and gas revenues falling this year by at least US$26.5 billion, President Muhammadu Buhari's government sees the dismissal of a $10bn judgement a...

READ FOR FREE

Fight in the last chance saloon

After hearing the arguments, a London court is about to rule on whether Abuja can challenge a record-breaking US$10 billion award against it

A substantial part of Nigeria's foreign financing strategy and the fortunes of a New York hedge fund, in partnership with an obscure entity registered in the British Virgin Islands...


Tinubu tries shock therapy on sluggish economy

Ending subsidies, selling oil assets and devaluing the naira are on the agenda as the new government goes for growth

Proclaiming the end of fuel subsidies at his inauguration on 29 May and his intention to merge the multiple exchange rates for the beleaguered naira, President Bola Tinubu signalle...

READ FOR FREE

After the boom, a purge

A Central Bank audit has uncovered evidence of fraud and mismanagement which implicates some leading politicians and their business partners

Like a family of latter day Medicis, Nigeria's top bankers have been prospering thanks to their acute political instincts and abilities to exploit their dominance in a tightly cont...