Jump to navigation

South Africa

Judicial system faces its own trial

Parliament to vote on investigation of Public Protector Mkhwebane accused of colluding with ex-President Zuma

Obsequies and judicial matters are set to dominate the agenda in South Africa this week. The country is debating the legacy of the Zulu King Goodwill Zwelithini, who had been a target of repression under the apartheid regime and then came under pressure again during the running clashes between the African National Congress and Inkatha in the early 1990s, orchestrated in part by the apartheid security forces. King Goodwill died on 12 March, aged 72; there will be a private funeral on 17 March and a public memorial on the following day.

President Cyril Ramaphosa described King Goodwill as a 'visionary leader' and the Thabo Mbeki Foundation lauded his 'commitment to nation-building'. Two journalists, Mondli Makhanya and Chris Barron, disagreed: Makhanya described Goodwill as a 'useful idiot in the hands of the apartheid government'; Barron recollected Goodwill's description of foreigners in South Africa as 'parasitic fleas' which coincided with a spate of xenophobic attacks and he accused the King of using the Ingoyama Trust as a 'giant piggy bank … extracting huge rents from more than 5 million rural farming people' (AC Vol 59 No 12, The tail that wags the dog).

On 16 March, parliament in Cape Town will debate launching a committee to investigate Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane who is accused of working covertly with the Jacob Zuma and Ace Magashule faction of the African National Congress against President Ramaphosa. An independent panel set up in November 2020 found prima facie evidence of misconduct and incompetence against her.

If parliament votes for the investigation into Mkhwebane, for which there is strong support from the pro-Ramaphosa ANC faction and the opposition Democratic Alliance, it will tie her up in personal legal battles, making her less useful to Magashule and Zuma, both of whom are fighting their own corruption charges.

The other judicial matters to watch are the fate of Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng, a Christian fundamentalist, who is facing the Judicial Conduct Committee to answer a complaint by the Africa4Palestine group that he made partisan statements about Israel. It could be settled by mediation.

More momentous is the case of Justice John Hlophe, Judge President of the Western Cape, who has just acquitted ANC MP Bongani Bongo, another close ally of Zuma and Magashule, of corruption charges. Anti-corruption groups and a former judge on the Constitutional Court, Johann Kriegler, criticised that decision and have called for Hlophe's suspension. Hlophe also faces accusations of assault against fellow judges and attempting to get the Constitutional Court to drop corruption charges against Zuma in 2008.

The fate of Mkhwebane and Hlophe will test the integrity and accountability of South Africa's judicial system but also play into the wider political battle between the pro and anti-Ramaphosa ANC factions.



Related Articles

The tail that wags the dog

In KwaZulu-Natal and other key provinces, the ANC’s divisions are deepening ahead of the 2019 elections

Making his second appearance in a KwaZulu-Natal (KZN) court at a short hearing on 8 June to face 16 charges of fraud and corruption, former President Jacob Zuma looked a grim and i...


Protection in the arms bazaar

A plea bargain deal in the UK and USA has set back investigations into arms trade crookery in South Africa and Tanzania

The US$450 million in fines that BAE Systems agreed to pay on 5 February to halt investigations into corrupt payments on arms deals adds to its financial woes. And it covers only p...


Fighting within the ranks

The EFF leadership is facing challenges from within amid allegations of corruption at the top of the party

Julius Malema's Economic Freedom Fighters has always prided itself on being a cohesive unit speaking with one voice but with a month to go before the party's elective conference, c...


Energy plan riles ANC factions and vested interests

The budget's debt relief for Eskom will impose targets and hasten privatisation but offers no short-term relief from power cuts

The explosive television interview by André de Ruyter, outgoing chief executive of ailing electricity utility Eskom on 21 February, which upstaged Finance Minister Enoch God...


NePAD doubts mount up

With its emphasis on new concepts of African collective responsibility and its promise of strong moral and financial support from Western countries, the New Partnership for African...