Jump to navigation

South Africa

Pretoria demands equal treatment to US on EU carbon border tax

Concessions to Washington are likely to ramp up opposition to levy

South Africa has stepped up its demands for concessions from the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) after Brussels’ recent deal with Washington. In a letter to the European Commission on 26 August, Xolelwa Mlumbi-Peter, deputy director of the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition, argues that South Africa and other developing economies should receive the same treatment the EU granted to the United States.

The 21 August framework agreement between the US and the EU, which sets out the deal on tariffs and other trade matters agreed by US President Donald Trump and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, promises ‘additional flexibilities’ for American firms under CBAM without spelling out the detail.

The levy, which will start being applied in the coming months, seeks to prevent EU industries from being undercut by requiring importers to pay a carbon price equivalent to that paid by European producers under the EU Emissions Trading System (AC Vol 64 No 13, How Brussels's green tax will hit Africa).

However, if US industry has obtained a blanket exemption from CBAM that would be poorly received by the likes of South Africa and India, who had previously threatened to take the EU to the World Trade Organization, claiming that CBAM breaches the WTO’s non-discrimination principle.

South Africa has been one of the leading critics of CBAM for some time, warning that its steel industry would be badly hit despite contributing little to global carbon emissions. South Africa's Presidential Climate Commission estimates that CBAM would cut Africa's exports to the EU by 30-35% – worth between €1.7 billion and €2.1bn – by 2030.

Concessions were also requested by Pretoria at a bilateral summit with the EU in March.

Carlos Lopes of the African Climate Foundation has warned that CBAM could lead to exports of aluminium to the EU from Africa dropping by 13.9%, and iron and steel by 8.2%

The EU Commission, however, has indicated that it plans to expand the scope of CBAM later this year (AC Vol 66 No 9, Blitzed by Trump tariffs, can Africa and Europe agree on trade?).



Related Articles

How Brussels's green tax will hit Africa

Europe's carbon levy has become law with African states in line to suffer collateral damage

After two years of debate, the European Parliament has passed a carbon pricing mechanism which will apply to all countries trading with member states of the European Union...


The 'Ramaphosa Compromise'

The medium-term budget is seen by some as a fudge in the struggle between liberalising reform and preserving the state sector

The government has firmly held the line against the left and the labour movement's efforts to defend ailing state-owned enterprises. President Cyril Ramaphosa is also boosting the Zondo...


Replaying the aid game

Transforming Europe means changing its post-colonial trade relations too

With ten new members coming aboard in May, a new constitution the subject of fierce debate and the European Parliament facing elections in May 2004, the European Union...


That golden moment

A foreign take-over of a local bank could mean the end of exchange controls

Barclays' planned purchase of ABSA (Amalgamated Banks of South Africa) is set to be the biggest foreign investment in post-apartheid South Africa. It cheers economic liberals, who argue...